Tandoc, Ferrucci and Duffy’s 2015 study asked whether heavy Facebook use leads to depression. In a survey of 736 US college students, heavy use alone was not linked to depression. Keeping track of other people’s posts was linked to envy, and envy was linked to depression. A survey like this shows links, not cause.
Key Takeaways
Aim
- To find out whether heavy Facebook use leads to depression in US college students.
- Social rank theory says feeling outranked, such as by friends who seem to be doing better, can lead to depression. The study measured this as envy.
Method
- An online survey of 736 college (university) students on beginner journalism courses at a large US university. About 68% were female and the average age was about 19.
- A survey is a self-report method: people answer questions about themselves. It can also be called a questionnaire.
- Students said how long they used Facebook and what they did on it. They rated eight statements about envy and completed a 20-item depression scale.
- Surveillance use means using Facebook to keep track of what others post. Network size means the number of Facebook friends.
- It was correlational: nothing was changed, so there is no independent variable. The co-variables (the things measured) were Facebook use, envy and depression.
Results
- Heavy Facebook use alone was not directly linked to depression.
- Hypothesis 1 (a prediction): heavy users feel more envy than light users. Supported.
- Hypothesis 2: people with more Facebook friends feel more envy. Not supported: the number of friends made no difference.
- Hypothesis 3: more envy goes with more symptoms of depression. Supported.
- Only surveillance use was linked to envy. Its effect on depression worked through envy.
Conclusion
- Facebook use does not directly lead to depression. The envy it can trigger is what matters, so social rank theory is a useful framework.
Strengths
- Large sample: 736 students took part, which is more than the researchers calculated they needed.
- Ecological validity: students answered about their real Facebook use, in their own time, so the results fit real life. (Ecological validity means how well results apply to everyday life.)
- Reliability: the envy scale was new, but it was tested and found to be consistent. (Reliability means getting consistent results.)
- Types of use were separated, so the study found that use can be harmless.
Limitations
- Social desirability: students may not have wanted to admit to being depressed, so they may have under-reported symptoms. (Social desirability means answering to look good.)
- Correlation: all measures were taken at one time, so the study cannot show that envy causes depression.
- Construct validity: the theory is about rank, but the study measured envy. (Construct validity means measuring what the study claims to measure.)
- Sample bias: the students were mostly young, female and White American, from one university, so the findings may not apply to others. This is age bias and cultural bias.
- Online method: the researchers could not check who completed the survey or how carefully.
Ethical Issues
- Protection from psychological harm: the depression questions could upset students. Way of dealing with it: give contact details for support services.
- Informed consent and right to withdraw: students were invited in class, so they may have felt pressure. Way of dealing with it: tell them taking part is voluntary and they can stop.
- Confidentiality: depression data are sensitive. Way of dealing with it: make the survey anonymous and use numbers, not names.
Exam Use
- For a describe question give both the procedure and the findings. Without both the top mark is lost. Do not add evaluation.
- For a weakness of the research method, focus on self-report, correlation or the online method, not the sample.
- Say “correlation, not cause” with a reason. A link between two things does not show one causes the other.
- The 13-mark question is the longest on the paper: you write an essay using two studies. This study has been used for an essay on validity (how sound and realistic research is).
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.
Background
Clinical depression means a long-lasting low mood.
It affects daily life. College students in the USA (university students) are often described as especially prone to it. College can mean new relationships, heavy workloads and life far from home.
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.
Some people think heavy use of sites such as Facebook adds to the problem. Earlier research did not agree.
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.
Social Rank Theory
The study used social rank theory. It is an evolutionary idea. It says a feeling developed to help our ancestors survive.
Social rank is where you stand compared with others, like a pecking order. Seeing friends who seem to be doing better than you can make you feel lower in that order.
When we lose rank, we can lose confidence in winning it back. Fighting to regain it risks more losses. Depression makes a person accept a lower place. Low energy and mood stop them competing. That reduces conflict, so it helped survival.
Applying It to Facebook
Facebook is mostly about showing your best side. People who see others looking more attractive may feel outranked. The researchers measured this feeling as envy.
Envy is wanting something that someone else has. It is not jealousy, which is fear of losing something to a rival. The authors assumed that Facebook use can lead to depression when it triggers envy.
Aim
The aim was to examine whether heavy Facebook use leads to depression among college students. The study used social rank theory to show that feelings of being outranked can trigger depression.
It asked three research questions and tested three hypotheses. A hypothesis is a prediction a study can test.
- Question 1: is there a link between how much people use Facebook and depression?
- Hypothesis 1: heavy Facebook users feel more Facebook envy than light users.
- Question 2: which uses of Facebook predict Facebook envy?
- Hypothesis 2: users with many Facebook friends (a big network) feel more Facebook envy than users with few.
- Question 3: does Facebook envy carry the link between Facebook use and depression?
- Hypothesis 3: people who feel more Facebook envy report more symptoms of depression.
OCR credits all three hypotheses in a description of the study.
Method
Design and Variables
The researchers ran an online survey. OCR calls it a self-report method and says it can also be called a questionnaire. Self-report means people answer questions about themselves.
It was a correlational study. A correlational study measures whether two or more things are linked and changes nothing. It was also cross-sectional: everything was measured from each student on one occasion.
- No independent variable: nothing was changed, so there is no independent variable.
- The co-variables: the three things measured were Facebook use, Facebook envy and depression symptoms. OCR calls variables measured in a correlation co-variables.
- Controls: the researchers made sure age and gender did not explain the results.
Facebook envy is the envy people feel after looking at other people’s information on Facebook. Surveillance use is using Facebook to keep track of what others post.
Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.
Sample
- Who: students from four classes on beginner journalism courses at a large university in the Midwest (the middle of the USA).
- How they were asked: the researchers visited the classes and sent email invitations. 854 students were invited and 736 took part, a participation rate of 86%.
- Make-up: about 68% were female, the average age was about 19, and 78% were White American. On average they used Facebook for about two hours a day.
Materials
- Facebook use: hours a day, and how often students did seven things, such as posting photos or reading the newsfeed. Four of these went together, so the authors grouped them as surveillance use.
- Facebook envy: eight statements about envy, such as “I generally feel inferior to others”. Students rated how far they agreed.
- Depression: a 20-item scale of symptoms called the CES-D, with items such as “I felt depressed”. Students rated how often each applied.
Procedure
- Students were invited in class and by email, and completed the survey online.
- The researchers removed invalid responses, leaving 736.
- They then compared the answers statistically, allowing for age and gender.
More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.
Results
- Question 1, use and depression: how much people used Facebook was not directly linked to depression.
- Hypothesis 1, supported: heavy users felt more Facebook envy than light users.
- Hypothesis 2, not supported: the number of Facebook friends did not matter.
- Hypothesis 3, supported: more envy went with more symptoms of depression. Envy was the only measure that clearly helped predict depression. Hours, friends, age and gender did not.
- Question 2, types of use: only surveillance use was linked to envy. Writing status updates or posting photos was not.
Question 3 asked whether envy carries the link. Surveillance use was not directly linked to depression overall. But it was linked to more envy, and envy was linked to more depression. So envy works as the go-between.
Once the envy route was set aside, surveillance use went with lower depression, by a modest amount. The authors say it can lessen depression when it does not trigger envy.
Conclusion
The study reached these conclusions.
- No direct link: Facebook use on its own does not directly lead to depression. When it does not trigger envy, it may even lessen depression.
- Envy matters: Facebook envy predicts depression symptoms. Heavy users and surveillance users feel more of it.
- It works through envy: the effect of surveillance use on depression runs through envy, as social rank theory predicted.
- A useful theory: the authors call social rank theory a useful framework. They say it is not the medium that is to blame but the feelings it can trigger.
The authors add their own cautions. Other factors also affect depression, envy has many causes, and the findings may not apply to all college students.
Strengths
- A large sample: 736 students took part, more than the 485 the researchers calculated they needed, and 86% of those invited took part. A large sample gives more reliable correlations.
- Reliability: the envy scale was new, but the authors tested it and found it consistent. The depression scale is widely used and was found reliable and valid in earlier research.
- Ecological validity: students answered about what they really do on Facebook, in their own time online. That fits real life better than a laboratory task.
- Types of use were separated: the study did not just ask whether Facebook is bad. It found that use can be harmless, which one overall result would have hidden.
- Easy to repeat: the questions and scales are printed in the paper, so others can run the survey again.
Limitations
- Self-report and social desirability: all three measures were answers to questions, so students may have answered to look good. Some may have guessed the topic and answered to fit (demand characteristics).
- Correlation, not cause: everything was measured at one time, so the study cannot show that envy or surveillance causes depression.
- Construct validity: the study measured envy, but the theory is about rank.
- Sample bias: the students were mostly female, White American and about 19, from one university. The authors say the findings may not fit all college students. This is age bias and cultural bias.
- The online method: the researchers could not check who answered or how carefully. Students without internet access, or who avoid Facebook, could not take part.
- Only part of the picture: depression was measured by symptom ratings, not a diagnosis, and other factors such as personality also matter.
- Reductionism: explaining something complex by one simple idea. Social rank theory explains depression by rank and envy and leaves out many other causes.
Correlation, Not Cause
This is the most important weakness to explain. Everything was measured once, so the study shows links between things. It does not show that one thing caused another.
Suppose envy and depression go together. Envy might lead to depression. Or depressed students might feel more envy. Or a third factor, such as low self-esteem, might raise both.
The paper uses wording such as “leads to”. But the design is a single survey, so these causes cannot be separated. Hypothesis 3 shows a link between envy and depression, not proof of cause.
Construct Validity: Envy or Rank?
Construct validity asks whether a study measures what it claims to measure. The theory is about rank and feeling defeated. The study did not measure rank.
It measured envy, using a new scale. The scale was new but was tested. Even so, envy may be a poor stand-in for feeling outranked.
Ethical Issues
The paper does not mention consent, ethical approval, anonymity or debriefing. So these are issues a student can raise.
- Protection from psychological harm: the scale asks about low mood and loneliness, which could upset some students. Way of dealing: give contact details for support services.
- Informed consent and right to withdraw: the researchers visited the classes, so students may have felt pressure. Way of dealing: say taking part is voluntary and students can skip questions or stop.
- Confidentiality: depression data are sensitive. Way of dealing: make the survey anonymous and use numbers, not names.
- Deception: none is reported. The survey asked directly about Facebook and depression.
Exam Questions
What OCR Asks About This Study
In the exam you get marks for these question types, all taken from OCR’s past papers on this study.
- Describe the study (6 marks): the top level needs both procedure and findings. Without either, the maximum is 4. Evaluation earns nothing.
- What the description should include: the three hypotheses, the method (an online self-report survey), the sample (students, journalism, USA, mostly female), the materials, and the results.
- One weakness of the method (2 marks): one mark is for a basic point and two for a developed one linked to the study.
- What counts as a method weakness: demand characteristics, reliability, construct validity, correlation and cause, or the online method. It must be about self-report, correlation or the online method, not the sample.
- 13 marks: an essay on issues of validity, using Tandoc et al. and a study from a different topic. Credited validity points include population, ecological and construct validity, demand characteristics and social desirability.
In a 13-mark answer, a study from the same topic cannot be the second study, so Daniel et al. does not work.
The three questions below are examples written in OCR’s style. They are not OCR’s own wording.
Practice Question 1: Describe the Study (6 marks)
Question [6 marks]: Describe Tandoc et al.’s study into Facebook use and depression.
Model answer: Tandoc et al. made three predictions. Heavy Facebook users would feel more envy than light users. People with big networks would feel more envy. More envy would go with more depression.
They gave an online self-report survey to 736 American college students on journalism courses. About 68% were female. The students said how much they used Facebook, rated eight envy statements, and completed a 20-item depression scale.
Heavy users felt more envy, but network size did not matter. More envy went with more depression. Facebook use on its own was not directly linked to depression.
- Mark scheme: levels, best fit. Level 3 (5 to 6): a thorough, clear, accurate description with both procedure and findings. Level 1 (1 to 2): basic.
- Level 2 (3 to 4): a clear, accurate description, with procedure and/or findings. If either procedure or findings is missing, the maximum is 4.
- Watch out: do not evaluate the study in a describe answer.
Practice Question 2: One Method Weakness (2 marks)
Question [2 marks]: Outline one weakness of the research method used in Tandoc et al.’s study into Facebook use and depression.
Model answer: One weakness is social desirability. The survey was self-report, so students may not have wanted to admit to being depressed. This means the depression scores may be too low.
- Mark scheme: 1 mark for a brief weakness and 2 for one developed and linked to the study. The weakness must be about self-report, correlation or the online method, not the sample.
Practice Question 3: Correlation and Cause (3 marks)
Question [3 marks]: Explain why Tandoc et al.’s findings do not show that Facebook envy causes depression.
Model answer: The study was a correlation. Everything was measured at one time, so it only shows that envy and depression go together. Depressed students may feel more envy, or a third factor such as low self-esteem may cause both.
- Example marking points (not the exam board’s own): 1 mark for a correlation or one-time measure. 1 mark for a link not being proof of cause. 1 mark for another explanation.
Later Research
Hanley and colleagues compared 40 people who took a week away from Facebook and Instagram with 38 who did not. The break did not make everyone happier. Some users had lower positive feelings afterwards, so the effect seemed to depend on how people used the sites (Hanley et al., 2019).
Beyens and colleagues followed 387 teenagers for three weeks. Social media use affected each teenager differently. For many it made no difference (Beyens et al., 2024).
So later work agrees that social media is not simply harmful and that how it is used matters.
More Simply Psychology Answers
Instant answers built on 19+ years of trusted expertise.
References
Beyens, I., Pouwels, J. L., van Driel, I. I., Keijsers, L., & Valkenburg, P. M. (2024). Social media use and adolescents’ well-being: Developing a typology of person-specific effect patterns. Communication Research, 51(6), 691-716. https://doi.org/10.1177/00936502211038196
Hanley, S. M., Watt, S. E., & Coventry, W. (2019). Taking a break: The effect of taking a vacation from Facebook and Instagram on subjective well-being. PLOS ONE, 14(6), Article e0217743. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0217743
Tandoc, E. C., Jr., Ferrucci, P., & Duffy, M. (2015). Facebook use, envy, and depression among college students: Is facebooking depressing? Computers in Human Behavior, 43, 139-146. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2014.10.053


